Shallow Water Farming: A Low-Cost Innovation

Long Island, NY farmers are successfully growing kelp in shallow waters, adapting traditional deep-water practices to their environment. When asked about the advantages, farmers highlight the low setup cost—just $50 for a hundred-foot line using two screw anchors and rope, compared to expensive deep-water systems. This method eliminates buoys, reducing both costs and visual impact. The simple setup takes just 15-20 minutes to install and allows farmers to work in waders rather than boats during adverse weather. Most importantly, kelp thrives in these shallow environments while helping improve water quality by removing nitrogen from areas with high runoff, creating both economic and environmental benefits.

Transcript

1
00:00:19.125 --> 00:00:23.705
One problem that I faced was where my oyster farm was,

2
00:00:23.705 --> 00:00:25.705
and a lot of other oyster farms are on Long

3
00:00:25.705 --> 00:00:26.865
Island or in shallow water.

4
00:00:27.885 --> 00:00:29.625
And the standard practice is

5
00:00:29.625 --> 00:00:32.425
to grow kelp along suspended lines in deeper water.

6
00:00:32.805 --> 00:00:34.665
Uh, but the logic being

7
00:00:34.665 --> 00:00:36.185
that the kelp does not touch the bottom.

8
00:00:37.685 --> 00:00:39.305
So that really wouldn't work in these

9
00:00:39.305 --> 00:00:40.545
shallow water environments.

10
00:00:41.365 --> 00:00:45.105
And as a scientist here at Stony Brook University,

11
00:00:45.625 --> 00:00:48.345
a few years ago with my, uh, colleague Chris Goler,

12
00:00:48.345 --> 00:00:51.145
we had written a proposal to look at just that,

13
00:00:51.285 --> 00:00:54.065
can we grow kelp in shallow water environments?

14
00:00:54.805 --> 00:00:56.785
And the shorter answer is yes.

15
00:01:02.045 --> 00:01:05.785
So in addition to achieving very good growth, there's, uh,

16
00:01:05.785 --> 00:01:07.985
several benefits to this shallow water system.

17
00:01:08.745 --> 00:01:10.345
Probably one of the biggest benefits is it's very

18
00:01:10.345 --> 00:01:11.465
inexpensive to set up.

19
00:01:12.205 --> 00:01:14.705
We can set up a hundred foot line, um,

20
00:01:14.755 --> 00:01:16.545
using just two screw down anchors

21
00:01:16.965 --> 00:01:19.905
and, uh, you know, a hundred feet of rope between them.

22
00:01:20.765 --> 00:01:22.905
The total cost for the setup is about $50.

23
00:01:23.615 --> 00:01:26.665
It's really a fraction of what it costs to set up a, uh,

24
00:01:26.665 --> 00:01:28.825
deeper water setup with a suspended line system

25
00:01:29.235 --> 00:01:30.865
where you have to buy bigger anchors.

26
00:01:31.165 --> 00:01:35.105
Um, sometimes chain to go from the anchors and buoys.

27
00:01:35.765 --> 00:01:37.585
Um, another great advantage

28
00:01:37.605 --> 00:01:39.025
of the Shallow West system is you don't have

29
00:01:39.025 --> 00:01:40.385
to use any buoys, okay?

30
00:01:40.405 --> 00:01:44.905
The lines are just pulled tight so they're tart, um,

31
00:01:45.635 --> 00:01:47.465
don't need buoys to help suspend the line.

32
00:01:48.085 --> 00:01:51.105
And, um, so not, not only does that reduce costs,

33
00:01:51.105 --> 00:01:53.145
but it also reduces, um,

34
00:01:53.775 --> 00:01:55.665
what some people might consider eye pollution.

35
00:01:55.665 --> 00:01:57.585
Some people might not wanna see buoys at the surface.

36
00:01:57.725 --> 00:02:00.505
So it really gives a very, you know, very low impact.

37
00:02:00.885 --> 00:02:04.905
We set up a very, very simple system, uh, on the farm.

38
00:02:05.175 --> 00:02:07.625
Just put two screw anchors in the farm, uh, with the heads

39
00:02:07.625 --> 00:02:10.105
of the screw anchors sticking about a foot

40
00:02:10.105 --> 00:02:11.225
up above the substrate.

41
00:02:11.525 --> 00:02:16.385
We ran a three eight inch poly line, uh, deployed the kelp,

42
00:02:16.965 --> 00:02:20.425
and lo and behold, it grew like wildfire.

43
00:02:25.295 --> 00:02:27.505
Another advantage is just the ease of setup.

44
00:02:27.855 --> 00:02:29.905
It's very, very, very easy to set up.

45
00:02:29.945 --> 00:02:31.825
I mean, you could set up a hundred foot line in

46
00:02:32.415 --> 00:02:33.785
15 minutes, 20 minutes.

47
00:02:33.895 --> 00:02:35.065
It's just very, very simple.

48
00:02:35.485 --> 00:02:38.865
Um, you don't have to deal with the weather.

49
00:02:39.165 --> 00:02:41.025
Uh, I mean, you do have, you have to deal with the weather,

50
00:02:41.125 --> 00:02:42.905
but weather isn't as much of a problem

51
00:02:43.175 --> 00:02:44.945
because you don't necessarily have

52
00:02:44.945 --> 00:02:47.185
to work from a boat in these shallow water environments.

53
00:02:47.185 --> 00:02:49.785
You put a pair of waiters on and you jump in the water.

54
00:02:49.845 --> 00:02:52.545
So if it's, you know, blowing too hard for a boat,

55
00:02:52.605 --> 00:02:53.865
you can still go do your work.

56
00:02:54.005 --> 00:02:57.825
So a lot of advantages of these shallow water systems,

57
00:02:58.305 --> 00:03:00.725
I think it actually outperformed many, uh,

58
00:03:00.725 --> 00:03:02.205
traditional deep water farms.

59
00:03:02.545 --> 00:03:04.645
And it was just a, it was a phenomenal experience

60
00:03:04.665 --> 00:03:07.645
to see this marine organism that, you know, started out

61
00:03:07.705 --> 00:03:10.245
as I say, like mere millimeters with almost

62
00:03:10.785 --> 00:03:11.805
no capital investment.

63
00:03:17.425 --> 00:03:19.325
The final thing I'll say is that in a lot

64
00:03:19.325 --> 00:03:21.245
of these shallow water environments, that's where some

65
00:03:21.245 --> 00:03:23.005
of the biggest water quality issues are.

66
00:03:23.185 --> 00:03:25.165
So that's where you have some of your biggest nitrogen

67
00:03:25.255 --> 00:03:28.445
loads, um, runoff in these shallow bays.

68
00:03:28.465 --> 00:03:31.205
So being able to grow sugar kelp

69
00:03:31.205 --> 00:03:33.325
and other seaweeds in these shallow environments has a,

70
00:03:33.565 --> 00:03:34.845
a great environmental value.

71
00:03:35.665 --> 00:03:38.285
So, um, yeah, a lot of advantages

72
00:03:38.465 --> 00:03:40.805
and benefits of growing kelp in, in shallow water.
Topics:

Featured Speakers:

Mike Doall
Stony Brook University
Paul McCormick
Great Gun Oysters